This is the second post in our three-part series, Secrets of Successful Book Proposals. Catch up on Part 1 here.
In Part 1, we covered how a strong proposal starts with a clear promise and a sharp differentiator. Like those lessons, the takeaways below come from a recent call that fellow LLA agent Kelly Bergh and I had with a nonfiction author about a new project. A great concept isn’t enough on its own: editors need to believe readers will care to keep reading for 250 pages. Here’s what we look for.
Make the reader’s transformation clear
Regardless of concept, good writing is non-negotiable. In Kelly’s words, “You can’t deny good writing, and you need the proposal to be the first demonstration of that.”
But readers have countless free sources of information, so your proposal has to answer their simplest question: What’s in this for me? Show what they’ll understand, feel, or be able to do differently by the end.
Know whether your book is a practice or an argument
If your book offers both an idea and a method, which one leads?
“I think the practice supersedes the argument,” Kelly said, because practical application makes a book prescriptive, and that label shapes which publishers are the right fit.
The distinction matters more than many writers realize, especially in a market where editors are responding to practical nonfiction in very different ways. We dig into this further in our post about author Ron Friedman, discussing what separates nonfiction that gets signed from nonfiction that doesn’t.
Give readers what they want before you show them what they need
This is a principle one of my own editors taught me, and I share it often. A lot of practical nonfiction comes at readers hard with the message. The books that work draw readers in first, through scenes and storytelling, before asking them to absorb the lesson.
I also encourage authors to make their books “AI proof.” Readers can get information anywhere now. What they can’t get elsewhere is your storytelling, your synthesis, and your distinct framework. (It’s also why agents can spot a proposal that leans too heavily on AI. I wrote about what agents notice in AI-generated book proposals here.)
Find the connective tissue
An ambitious book can combine several subjects. The risk isn’t too many interesting ideas; it’s ideas so broad that the book can’t make one clear promise.
I call what holds them together the “connective tissue”: how every concept ladders up to the central idea. Kelly adds that you need an identifiable through line, a focused niche, and a punchy title.
Finding that through line in your own project is hard to do alone. It’s often the first thing we work on with authors, and it’s one reason we encourage writers to get expert feedback on their book before querying agents.
Coming up next
In Part 3, we’ll cover author platform, publishing history, and how to find the right path to a deal.
Ready to pressure-test your own proposal? Book a private consultation with our team.



